Saturday, March 18, 2006

Roryshock Throws Another Human/Animal Distinction on the Slagheap of History: Claim that Wild Animals Don't Act Debunked

There are some who claim that the ability to ACT is what makes us human and distinguishes us from “the animals.” As an aside, rory is pretty frickin’ sick of people worried about distinguishing the naked ape from the rest of nature. What’s the frickin’ point of that? First it was “tool use.”
Oh, the animals don’t use tools. We, humans, however, use, and in many cases, are, tools. Jane Goodall and others laid the “tool use” horseshit to rest by observing chimps using sticks to procure food, by using hammer and anvil to break nuts, etc. We still hear plenty of this shit from people obsessed with separating us from “the animals” in keeping with the bible which is the authority that establishes we have “dominion” over "them" and are better than "them". Fuck that shit. The pseudoscientific bible-thumpers claim that animals don’t have “spirituality,” “altruistic behavior,” “ability to use language,” or “high intelligence in general.” rory sez: horseshit, holmes. rory sez: by these definitions, a feller who doesnt’ know his anus from his ankle, such as George W. Bush, is less human than, say, Kanzi, the human language learnin', tool fabricatin' Bonobo.

Those who make a living out of human-animal-distinction-ruminative-beard-pulling and-pontification (so far most of the yahoos I’ve found who are obsessed with this shit are indeed male neked apes) are becoming increasingly desparate to find new unassailable areas of distinction. That’s why they came up their latest claim: “Animals do not act.' One renowned zoologist, Dr. Bivin Tumblewad, said, “I mean there are no Bonobo Oliviers, now are there? No reptilian Ralph Richardsons. No pachyderm Pacinos. No whale Witherspoons. No canine Clooneys.” rory sez: I think you missed “no Turtle Tumblewads” doc, you frickin’ fuckwad.


But seriously, rory contacts Dr. Tumblewad and says, “hey doc,” and rory can hardly keep a straight face as he says “Tumblewad,” but that’s his frickin’ real name, okay, I got proof that there are reptilian Ralph Richardsons. I mean, the hognose snake, it does a death scene like nobody. Here, man, check out these pictures rory took:



I’m always impressed when I see this performance. I mean they flop over, they prolapse their cloacas, they emit musk, their jaw opens, their tongue dangles out. And it’s all an act! Talk about a frickin’ performance doc! Yeah, I know plenty of human actors can conjure up tears on demand. But name one Oscar winner who can prolapse the old cloaca and emit musk, then roll over, slither off, and do it again with feeling moments later, if the muse calls. Name me frickin’ one, man.”



Tumblewad was ready for this one. “Mr. Shock, I have studied animal behavior as a professional for my entire career. As a scientist, I cannot draw conclusions from mere anecdotal observations. Additonally, “playing dead” is hardly acting. Why by your logic, we’d have to include opossums. Dogs have been trained to “play dead” as well. This type of rote behavior is either “hard-wired” into the animal or trained into the animal by humans. And, I think even you know, humans don’t have cloacas."

rory sez: see what I frickin’ mean. You just can’t reason with these fuckers. And a by-the-way: the first three hognose snake pix are worth clickin' on to enlarge, in roryz humble opinion.

21 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yurggh. The "anecdotal" bit is too true--even in the sciences. Heaven forbid we "anthropomorphize" anything (or anyone?), even if it's accurate.

Keep 'em coming Rory!

9:20 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

dearest mr shock, those that say animals cannot 'act' never met any of MY hounds from hell. ranger danger (my neice named him but i called him b.u.t., big ugly thaing, it's ok, he KNEW i was just joshin') used to limp when people were watching him but if he thought he was unobserved, HE WALKED JUST FINE. that is but one example

9:36 AM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

yeah no6 ... "anthropomorphization" love that one ... that's a no-no on the one hand and "animalization" of the "anthros" is on the other ... too many damn "zations" ... observation is a good one though

rose: cool that's a great animal acting storie ... I wuz hopin' this would elicit some good animal actin' stories ... what was he doin' makin' himself less threatening to humor the humans? dogs are so frickin' RICH ... love it ... tried to comment over at your place without success earlier ... gonna try again

10:22 AM  
Blogger Peacechick Mary said...

Actually, most people run into a problem when they keep trying to prove man is superior to animals. Not true, in fact I think this mindset is the basis for all bigotry. If he/she/it is different, then I must be superior. Beautiful colorations on the snake.

10:36 AM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

well said mary

10:46 AM  
Blogger Beth said...

Oh Mr. Shock, you post pictures of snakes that give me the willies.

Every spring when I can finally hang the laundry out on the line, the snakes like to come and suntan on my patio.

Let's just say...they do make me dance, ugh.

Hoping you are well.

4:53 PM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

well. Lizzy ... doin' okay ... for some people its clowns, for others snakes ... me its clowns I guess ... man I wish I had snakes visible when I was hangin' out the laundry ... clowns on the other hand ... talk about givin' the willies!
I'm doin' okay ... hope you are too ...

6:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

love your way with words. well, all my animals "act" but only one "sings", does that count? Not just howling, but trying to form words with her big soft Labrador mouth. We never taught her any of this, but she recognizes & "sings" The Star Spangled Banner, Amazing Grace, The Marine Corp Hymn & (in German) Beethoven's Ode to Joy. D.K.

10:22 PM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

anonymous ... beautiful comment there ... the lab should record ...

12:47 AM  
Blogger Yukkione said...

Lets not forget that Democratic leadership is great at playing dead too. It's not hard for them because they have such weak pulses.

4:29 AM  
Blogger gugon said...

Great post!

I know what separates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom: Our amazing capacity for self-delusion and overinflated self-importance. Oh yea, and our un-matched cruelty.

6:19 AM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

loc: yeah, I think I've mistaken a couple of them for hognoses

gugon: right on I dig your comment

7:29 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I second gugon !! He/She captured it in a nutshell !!

8:34 AM  
Blogger Graeme said...

i got to go with gugon. When I was growing up I had a dog that was much smarter than a lot of people I know. we have conviced ourselves of our importance

2:10 PM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

yeah anita and graeme

3:49 PM  
Blogger Yellow Dog said...

OK,rory. Usally I am just plain too dumbfounded to post comments. I had to wait until I could see thru the tears to post this one. My wife hates eing the passsenger in a vehicle (almost always a pickup) that I am driving because I am the only person on the GD planet that knows how to drive which is what separates me from all of you lesser life forms.

As Kurt Vonnegut says, the Earths immune system is trying to get rid of us. We might be self-aware, but all that means is that we realie that we are finite. We can't deal with that shit so we make up a god an ever-after life.

I had a teacher who told me thatour ability to conceptualize infinty is what separates us from the "beasts". If we truly had the ability to conceptualize infinity, we'd realize how assinine our petty narcicism is.

3:59 PM  
Blogger Yellow Dog said...

Rose:

That's really weird. Myboy nicknamed y od pickup BUT(big ugly truck)

4:00 PM  
Blogger Yellow Dog said...

I have keys on my keyboard that stick. I really should proofread when spellcheck isn't available.

4:05 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

lol yellow dog!

2:06 AM  
Blogger Rory Shock said...

yellow dog ... well Kurt's right eh ... if we could conceptualize infinity we'd be a lot more aware of just how soon in the great cosmic scheme of time the anti-bodies will knock out the biggest nuisance species to spread around the spinnin' rock like mold on an old orange ... I love hearing people's "what separates us from the beasts stories" I'm gonna post on that ... yellow dog proofing is overrated ... and its never too late when you're blogging ... least that's what I tell myself ...

4:46 AM  
Anonymous generic cialis said...

I, of course, a newcomer to this blog, but the author does not agree

1:51 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home